Roof Repair or Replacement-Pros and Cons - Featured Image.jpg

Roof Repair or Roof Replacement: Pros and Cons of Each

When it comes to changing or updating your roof, you basically have two options: roof repair or roof replacement. Roof repair entails removing just the sections or components of a roof that are damaged or faulty. Roof replacement means just that, complete removal of the old roof and replacing it with a new one.

Both practices have benefits and potential drawbacks depending on your current situation or what your desired end goals are. As a trusted roofing contractor in Wilmington, Tycos Roofing can provide an expert recommendation tailored to your specific situation and needs. Now, let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons when considering a roof repair or roof replacement.

Roof Repair

Pros

One obvious and significant pro about a roof repair is that it is almost always less expensive than a roof replacement short term. If upfront cost is a significant factor, roof repair may be the best option. Another pro about roof repair is, depending on the extent of the repair, that it takes less time than a full roof replacement. Time can be a critical factor since a roof repair may minimize potential exposure to the elements.

Cons

The biggest con of roof repair is compatibility. Roofing materials change over time, so depending on how old your current roof is, there may be some compatibility issues between the existing and new roofing materials. Roofing contractors may also utilize different techniques, so if you use different roofing contractors, there could be issues with consistency.

While short term cost is generally a pro for roof repair, the cost in the long term may be a significant con. If a roof repair is done poorly or doesn’t fix the issue, it can lead to greater costs down the road.

Roof Replacement

Pros

Roof replacement has some pretty appealing pros as well. First and foremost, a roof replacement typically mitigates the compatibility issues that might surface with just a roof repair. And if there are any issues, they can be addressed for the entire roof at once instead of piecemeal through numerous roof repairs.

Another appealing pro is that roof replacements typically come with a standard warranty that covers the entire roof instead of leaving you potentially liable if roof issues persist outside of a repaired area.

Cons

The biggest and most obvious con for a roof replacement is the significant upfront cost. It’s an investment, but may not be feasible given your current situation. Another con could possibly be time. A roof replacement generally takes longer than a roof repair, so if the work needs to be done quickly a roof repair may be a better option.

In any case, a trusted roofing contractor like Tycos Roofing can review your roofing needs and provide an expert recommendation about whether a roof repair or roof replacement is right for you.